Cats can be picky little prudes about nearly anything they feel like. From getting a food recipe wrong to petting them on the wrong part of their back or at the wrong time of day, cats can be—well, particular. When it comes to collars, they might really get unhappy for a variety of creative reasons.
If your cat loathes collars like the dickens, then it’s time to get them a pleasing wearable item. We rounded up 10 of the best collars we could find for those finicky felines of yours. Here are reviews of what we picked out of the pack as the best contenders for your picky pet.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
|Best Overall||Hepper Hemp Breakaway Cat Collar||
|Best Value||MJIYA Cat Collar||
|Premium Choice||Kittyrama Cat Collar||
|Best for Kittens||Pettsie Kitten Collar||
|PetSkoo Clover Cat Collar||
The 10 Best Cat Collars for Cats Who Hate Collars
1. Hepper Hemp Breakaway Cat Collar – Best Overall
Cats that hate collars may grow to love our #1 best overall choice. The Hepper Breakaway Cat Collar is a comfortable, attractive collar that gets softer and comfier with time. The material it’s made from natural hemp, which is durable but also lightweight and soft. This is one collar that won’t cause your cat discomfort or skin irritation. One of the best qualities of natural hemp is that, as it ages, it gets even softer. In other words, the longer your cat wears it, the more comfortable the Hepper cat collar will be on its fur.
One notable feature is the collar’s quick release (i.e., breakaway) clasp, which could save your cat’s life if it gets caught on a branch, snagged on a fence, or entangled in another obstacle. Breakaway clasps are a must for outdoor cats but could also be a lifesaver for a curious indoor cat, depending on your home’s interior. The only drawback is that if it breaks away outside, your cat’s excellent Hepper collar might be lost forever.
It’s worth noting that the Hepper Breakaway Cat Collar is made in the United States. It also comes with a small bell to alert you (and your local birds and other animals) of your cat’s presence. Lastly, the Hepper Breakaway Cat Collar is UV and mold-resistant and comes in several attractive pastel colors. For all of these reasons, it’s our choice for the best overall cat collar for cats who hate collars.
At Excitedcats.com we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest, so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!
- Breakaway collar clasp for safety
- Made of durable, soft, natural hemp
- Several attractive colors to choose from
- Adjustable to 11 inches
- Gets softer and comfier as it ages
- Some cat owners might not want or need a bell
- Breakaway clasp increases the risk of lost collars
2. MJIYA Cat Collar – Best Value
If you’re a fan of Buffalo check print, you may want to look at the MJIYA Cat Collar. It has an entirely adorable design, equipped with all the right elements that make your cat calm down about wearing it. Not only is it adorable, but it’s also the best cat collar for cats who hate collars for the money.
This good-looking collar comes in tons of color choices—red, blue, black, green, orange, and pink. You can choose the one that suits your handsome feline the best. The material is strong nylon that holds up wonderfully with rough wear.
The D-ring attachment and bell are anti-corrosive stainless steel, so you won’t have to worry about rusting-plus, it ups the durability of the product. The adorable buckle is a cat-shaped breakaway design. However, the plastic buckle does feel just a little flimsy.
- Anti-corrosive metal
- Durable nylon webbing
- Flimsy buckle
3. Kittyrama Cat Collar — Premium Choice
We absolutely adored the Kittyrama Cat & Kitten Collar because of its weightless wear and attractive design, but it’s a bit pricier than most. The entire collar is practical and well-made, able to withstand long-term use while causing minimal irritation.
This collar is available in lots of color selections—tangerine, Bermuda, mauve, meadow, aqua, Havana, Monte Carlo, and Tahiti. If those interesting names aren’t enough to catch your attention, the bell is removable. So, if the noise irritates your cat, this is a handy option.
The collar is made of waterproof silicone, provides wear that is resistant to scratches, bites, and tears—and it’s flexible. The unique breakaway clasp is quick and easy to buckle, too.
We enjoyed this collar for all its aesthetics and comfort, but the silicone collar might be a little fragile. It seems instead of breaking away at the buckle, as they’re more prone to splitting the silicone seams.
- Pleasing aesthetic
- Super lightweight
- Slightly fragile
4. Pettsie Kitten Collar – Best for Kittens
We love the stylish look of the Pettsie Kitten Collar. It is incredibly attractive and gender-neutral, coming in two selections: yellow or blue. Plus, not only do you get a snazzy collar for your little bundle of joy, you get a matching friendship bracelet to solidify your bond.
This product is made from 100% cotton, touting a lightweight, irritation-free feel. It is very soft and bendable right out of the box with no need to break it in. It has ultra-breezy adjustment points that stay in place without loosening.
If you know someone who just got a kitten, this will make an adorable gift idea. It comes in a neatly packaged box set up as a gift. But there’s no reason you can’t treat yourself! The plastic-free box is just another way you can feel environmentally conscious.
- Environmentally friendly packaging
- 100% soft cotton
- Adorable gift idea
- For kittens only
5. PetSokoo Four-Leaf Clover Cat Collar
|Material:||Japanese crepe fabric|
For the disgruntled cat, we think the PetSokoo Four-Leaf Clover Cat Collar is a smart design. It is a very unique addition to our list—and 100% handmade for a personal touch. We think it would look great on any feline.
This collar has a Japanese crepe cherry blossom printed fabric—available in three colors: Sakura pink, baby blue, and orange-yellow. We think any furry guy or gal would look charming in this design. However, it might not match everyone’s style preferences.
This collar is incredibly soft and totally hypoallergenic to protect your cat’s skin and neck. The tough plastic breakaway buckle is efficient but seamless to snap and unsnap. There is a D-ring attachment with a bell where you can place tags for your kitty.
Our favorite thing about this collar was the adjustable point. Rather than having an attractive adjustment piece, it’s all fabric, adjusting evenly on both sides for an aesthetically pleasing touch.
- Unique design
- Effective adjustment points
- Might not be attractive to some
6. Nuvuq Comfortable Cat Collar
If your cat isn’t a big fan of collars, we really think you should try the Nuvuq Comfortable Cat Collar. We found the collar to be extremely lightweight and easy to put on, which is very helpful if your cat is about to fight you in the process.
You can buy this collar in five spectacular colors: blueberry blue, black pepper, lime green, raspberry pink, and tangerine orange. So, no matter how much your cat can’t stand it, they’re sure to roam in style.
This hypoallergenic collar is perfect for sensitive skin. So, if your cat is constantly itching with other collars, this might be your go-to move. You can adjust it easily, clean it with a basic wipe down, and even attach ID tags to it.
This anti-fraying, durable rubber collar is our favorite overall—and we think most hasty cats will approve. However, there is always a chance it might not match the issue at hand.
- Soft, strong material
- Easy to clean
- It might not work for all cats
7. Frisco Rose Polyester Breakaway Collar
The Frisco Rose Polyester Breakaway Collar is a fantastic choice, permitting your cat approves. The sides have subtly contoured edges that curve to provide comfort on the neck.
This polyester-webbed collar has a beautiful floral design, but if you prefer another color, check out other options for this particular model—they’re all quite snazzy. The bell stands alone apart from the D-ring attachment and isn’t removable like some other collars.
This collar is equipped with a breakaway buckle designed to break away at 11 to 15 pounds. Adjustments slide and stay easy peasy, with no hassle to get the perfect fit.
Our only complaint is that the bell is quite loud. It might be a little ear-piercing for some. You could remove the bell, but you’d have to use a tool and hope for the best. If the sound doesn’t bother you, it is a durable design that looks awesome!
- Contoured edges for added comfort
- Very strong composition
- Many pattern options
- Loud bell
8. Red Dingo Skulls & Roses Nylon Breakaway Collar
We really enjoyed the Red Dingo Skulls & Roses Nylon Breakaway Collar because it’s thinner but hard-wearing so you can give your cat maximum protection with minimal material. Plus, did we mention it’s super appealing?
This particular Red Dingo collar has adorable skulls and roses with red backing. But you can also choose a green reflective or pink breezy love option. They all are made exactly the same and are pretty darn adorable.
The buckle on this collar is a quick-release safety fish clip. This clasp will separate if tension is applied to the collar, ensuring your little one can get out of danger if they’re stuck. The nylon material is soft and abrasion-resistant for optimal durability and comfort. We also love that it’s machine washable!
We have no major complaints overall, but we will mention that this one might be easy for your cat to pop off if they really don’t like it. The clasp comes apart quite easily, which is great for emergencies but not so much for displeased cats.
- Soft nylon material
- Machine washable
- Unisex design
- Might be easy to pop off
9. Murom Breakaway Collar
The Murom Breakaway Cat Collar is made from soft leather material that is an excellent pick for cats who don’t like collars. It is incredibly bendable and comfortable—your cat should forget it’s even there in no time.
This selection is not only functional—it’s very attractive as well. It comes in nine different color choices: blue, aquamarine, brown, dark brown, graphite, green, peach, pink, and red. It comes with a matching metallic jingle ball located on the D-ring attachment (which can be removed if not desired.)
The buckle and adjustable point are both made of heavy-duty plastic. The breakaway mechanism is very on par. It didn’t snap away with minimal effort, meaning your cat can try to claw it off and achieve no real success. But it still comes apart as it should with proper pressure applied.
This particular collar is suitable for adults only, even though some juveniles might do fine. Kittens, even at the highest adjustment level, will likely be too small for this collar. Just to be safe, full-grown cats should get all the consideration for this design.
- Soft leather for comfy wear
- Many color choices
- Removable bell
- For adult cats only
10. BRONZEDOG Tribal Breakaway Cat Collar
The BRONZEDOG Tribal Breakaway Cat Collar is a terrific choice for visibility. Even if your cat hates the feel of a collar, they will stand out and be heard. We loved the simplicity but effectiveness of this product—and you get two pieces for a reasonable price!
This eye-catching collar comes in three color choices: Aztec sunrize, sherape dark blue, and southwest lime green, and Mexican sunset. Each one is bright and bold with a D-ring attachment (silver bell included.)
This product is made of nylon webbing that is super lightweight and durable. It’s completely sufficient for everyday wear, or you can use it on occasion if your cat travels out. It’s ideal for visibility but will break away as it’s designed.
However, we noticed that the ends might fray over time, especially if they claw at it to get it off. It’s not as durable as some like products, but we still think it deserves an honorable mention.
- Bold color
- Ends might fray quickly
- Slightly less quality than similar products
Buyer’s Guide: Selecting The Best Cat Collar for Cats Who Hate Collars
Some cats don’t like collars for similar reasons they don’t like clothes—it’s something on them restricting their body against their will. If it’s making them uncomfortable, they’re going to be pretty perturbed about having to wear it regularly.
Softer materials that are lightweight might work to alleviate a little of the bother.
Some cats might hear the bell but not reach it—which can be really aggravating. If they seem irritated about the noise, you can try to remove the bell on their collar, or simply buy one without. Certain collars have optional bells that are very easy to remove. Others, you have to clip it off.
If the bells are a problem for your frisky feline, you can solve it easily, no matter what method or approach you take.
Some materials, especially those treated with synthetic dyes, can cause physical irritation on the skin. If your cat can’t seem to quit digging, looking for hypoallergenic options might work best for this situation. When you’re shopping, look for allergy-free descriptions.
Sometimes, if a collar is too loose, it can rub around the neck. This can cause hair loss or skin irritation. Make sure that your cat’s collar is snug, but you can still fit two fingers between their skin and the collar. That is the general rule of thumb.
Measure before purchase every time to prevent returns and incorrect fit.
For some high-energy cats and many kittens, buckles can pose a huge problem—and safety risk. If your cat is constantly romping around, they might get their collar caught on various items around the house. To keep them safe, breakaway collars will help release the buckle to prevent choking.
If your cat has choked before, it can cause an issue with collars in the future. Get a collar that won’t snag or strangle them if they get themselves into a pickle to rebuild their trust.
Some materials might be too heavy or rub on your cat. Lighter materials like silicone might help alleviate some of the discomforts.
Over the others, we liked the Hepper Hemp Breakaway Cat Collar. It is soft, flexible, and lightweight. Your cat will barely notice it’s on. Also, it’s affordable on most budgets, so you won’t have to worry too much about the cost.
Now, if you’re looking for the biggest savings you can find, try out the MJIYA Cat Collar. It’s super adorable, very price-friendly, and you can choose from a variety of check prints. The nylon material should hold up very well for everyday use, so it’s well worth every penny.
Regardless of what collar caught your eye, we hope it gains the approval of your typically disapproving feline.
Featured Image Credit: Chewy
- A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2023
- The 10 Best Cat Collars for Cats Who Hate Collars
- 1. Hepper Hemp Breakaway Cat Collar – Best Overall
- 2. MJIYA Cat Collar – Best Value
- 3. Kittyrama Cat Collar — Premium Choice
- 4. Pettsie Kitten Collar – Best for Kittens
- 5. PetSokoo Four-Leaf Clover Cat Collar
- 6. Nuvuq Comfortable Cat Collar
- 7. Frisco Rose Polyester Breakaway Collar
- 8. Red Dingo Skulls & Roses Nylon Breakaway Collar
- 9. Murom Breakaway Collar
- 10. BRONZEDOG Tribal Breakaway Cat Collar
- Buyer’s Guide: Selecting The Best Cat Collar for Cats Who Hate Collars