10 Best Cat Toys on Chewy 2020 – Reviews & Top Picks

Last Updated on: October 27, 2020

kitten is playing with a ball_Chendongshan_shutterstockBuying toys for your cat involves taking a risk almost every time. Older cats, however, are often not easy to please. If you have a kitten, it can be easier because they are interested in nearly everything.

Finding the right toy for your cat often involves knowing them well enough to know what they like. Think about the things that have held their interest in the past. Do they enjoy batting around balls that light up? Do they like feathers, toys that make noise, or quick movements?

After you have made a mental list of your cat’s interests and disinterests, take a critical look through these 10 best cat toys on Chewy. They have been carefully selected based on how many cats find them engaging and the input level that they require from you.

If you still don’t know what to get your cat, read through the buyer’s guide. This can help you determine what to try out first. Buying loads of toys that your cat isn’t interested in can be disheartening, so you might as well start with the best.

Cat ball divider 1A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Catit Design Senses Circuit Cat Toy Catit Design Senses Circuit Cat Toy
  • Great toy for a multi-cat family
  • Easy to expand track with more pieces
  • Light-up ball entices cats to come to play
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Bergan Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy Bergan Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy
  • Distracts cats from scratching furniture
  • Available extensions keep it interesting
  • Catnip in the design makes it even more alluring
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    PetFusion Interactive Electronic Cat Toy PetFusion Interactive Electronic Cat Toy
  • Randomized feather action engages a cat’s prey drive
  • 8-minute auto-shutoff saves battery power
  • Replacement feathers and batteries come with the initial purchase
  • Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy
  • Small enough to be non-intrusive
  • Bright color and three levels to engage cats
  • Non-skid pads on the bottom to keep it from sliding
  • SmartyKat Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy SmartyKat Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy
  • Automation allows cats to self-play
  • Different speeds for cat customization
  • Varying attachments to keep it interesting
  • 10 Best Cat Toys on Chewy — Reviews 2020

    1.  Catit Design Senses Circuit Cat Toy — Best Overall

    Catit Design Senses

    Need to get your kitty a little more active than they have been? This cat toy from Catit Design might be just the way to do it. It might seem simple, but it engages almost any cat that interacts with it.

    The toy is in the shape of an “S,” making a circuit with a swirl-patterned ball inside of it. There are spaces at different intervals and angles along the ball’s track, which is expandable. Some of them are longer, where the cat can bat at it and move it, while others might only allow a quick paw inside.

    Intelligent cats can figure out how to pop the end off the track and steal the ball, but this is relatively rare.

    This cat toy does not take up much space and is also quite affordable. Since there is a whole track that the ball can rocket down, you can play with your cat or two cats can play simultaneously.

    Pros
    • Easy to expand track with more pieces
    • Great toy for a multi-cat family
    • Light-up ball entices cats to come to play
    Cons
    • Ends can pop off

    2.  Bergan Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy — Best Value2Bergan Star Chaser Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy

    The Bergan Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy is small and simple in its conceptual design, but it is ranked as one of the most engaging toys for your kitties. These toys are circular, with two primary rings.

    Inside the innermost ring is a scratcher pad, made from cardboard in a sort of woven pattern. When your cat scratches over the top of it, their nails run over and through the texture of the cardboard in an engaging way. It helps distract them from scratching at other materials, like your furniture.

    The outer ring is curved and has a small metal LED ball that runs around it. They love following it around the circle, scratching against the cardboard as they chase it. The ball might pop out of some designs. There is also catnip in the design to make it even more alluring.

    This toy from Bergan has extension options to keep it continuously interesting. There is a grooming arch extension with a feather that hangs down. There are other feathers and toy extensions that you can place in and around it.

    Pros
    • Distracts cats from scratching furniture
    • Available extensions keep it interesting
    • Catnip in the design makes it even more alluring
    Cons
    • The ball doesn’t always stay in

    3.  PetFusion Interactive Electronic Cat Toy — Premium Choice3PetFusion Ambush Interactive Electronic Cat Toy

    When you do not have enough energy to entertain your cat, the PetFusion Interactive Electronic Cat Toy can do it for you.

    This toy is a premium choice, but it isn’t that much more expensive than some other products’ prices. It has plenty of features that make it well worth it. There are feathers on a rod inside the machine and holes around the exterior.

    When switched onto either blue or purple, the feathers will begin to pop out of the machine at random intervals and places. They move back and forth slightly before receding inside. Cats go wild following these and trying to catch them. It is noisy, which can engage them but can also scare them.

    If your cat “wins” by catching the feathers, then the company offers replacement parts to keep the fun going. There is one replacement feather included in the initial purchase.

    There is an 8-minute auto-shutoff feature, so it won’t keep going all night long. To stop it from being pushed around the house, there are anti-slip feet on the bottom. It requires 4 AA batteries, which come with the initial purchase.

    Pros
    • Randomized feather action engages a cat’s prey drive
    • Replacement feathers and batteries come with the initial purchase
    • 8-minute auto-shutoff saves battery power
    Cons
    • Noisy and disruptive in some households

    4.  Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy4Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy

    This brightly colored cat toy tower is meant to be engaging on multiple different levels. There are three cylindrical tubes, each one of which opens on the outside and hosts a ball. These are all colored differently and can spin around their respective levels.

    Even though the middle of the tower is hollowed out, there is a safety bar across the top. This bar functions to protect curious kitties from getting stuck while they explore the interior. Your cat will never lose another ball underneath your furniture but instead, gets to chase them around these three exciting levels.

    On the bottom of the tower, there are non-skid pads to stop it from sliding while your cat plays with it. But it doesn’t have too much weight to it and can flip over when an excited kitty gets ahold of it. Multiple cats can use it at the same time. It doesn’t take up too much space, being only 10 inches in diameter and 5 inches high.

    Pros
    • Bright color and three levels to engage cats
    • Non-skid pads on the bottom to keep it from sliding
    • Small enough to be non-intrusive
    Cons
    • Not heavy enough to always stay upright

    5.  SmartyKat Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy5SmartyKat Hot Pursuit Electronic Concealed Motion Cat Toy, Blue

    Another automated toy, this time from SmartyKat. It is an electronic concealed motion cat toy. It looks like a low-ground tent on the floor, a piece of fabric that is upheld slightly in the middle. It is from this point that a short rod sticks out that has feathers on its end.

    These feathers are controlled by the electronic center concealed under the fabric. They can swing around, be pulled in and pushed further out, or perpetually move. The toy is meant to awaken the inner tiger in your furry friend and spur them on to chase the feathers.

    You can set the toy to move at different speeds so it doesn’t overwhelm older cats but still engages younger ones. There are also a variety of toy attachments available to mix up the fun. It lights up in the center as well. Since the wand can be detached to customize it, there is a risk that smart cats will detach it and run away instead of playing with the toy.

    Pros
    • Automation allows cats to self-play
    • Different speeds for cat customization
    • Varying attachments to keep it interesting
    Cons
    • Fabric can get tangled in nails sometimes
    • Detachable wand is no match for smart cats

    6.  Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy6Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy

    This cat toy from Frisco is similar to the tower toy listed above, but with a little more variation. There are three levels that each have small balls that slide around and circle the tower. The center of the toy is not hollow, to prevent cats from getting stuck inside.

    On the top of the toy, there is a butterfly attachment that sticks out from the top on a slender wire. It easily moves back and forth to make it appear as though the butterfly were fluttering around the top of the toy.

    Frisco includes an extra butterfly piece with the first purchase so if the first one breaks, you have an immediate replacement. The bottom is equipped with nonskid pads to stop the toy from sliding around during playtime. It isn’t that heavy, though, so it can be flipped over during an aggressive playtime.

    Pros
    • Includes replacement butterfly pieces
    • Three layers give it plenty of allure
    • Bottom has non-skid pads
    Cons
    • Toy can tip over during playtime

    7.  SmartyKat Feather Whirl Electronic Motion Cat Toy7SmartyKat Feather Whirl Electronic Motion Cat Toy

    Another electronic toy from SmartyKat, this toy is unobtrusive and works via batteries to entertain your cat for hours. It is a ball with two parts that twist on the top and the bottom. Plugged into the top is a rod with a feather on the top.

    When this toy is turned on, the ball’s weighted base causes it to roll around erratically. The feathers are made to jerk back and forth at random times to engage your cat’s hunting instinct. The ball moves around the floor but operates with a whisper-quiet motor. That means it doesn’t scare your cat, and it doesn’t bother you.

    The motor requires two AA batteries, which are not included. There are replacement wands available for purchase as well, but there are no extras that come with it.

    Pros
    • Weighted base helps keep the toy upright
    • Whisper-quiet motor doesn’t scare your cat
    • Only requires two batteries
    Cons
    • Does not include batteries or extra parts

    8.  Catit Design Senses Illuminated Balls Cat Toy8Catit Design Senses Circuit Motion Activated Illuminated Balls Cat Toy

    Sometimes simple is best when it comes to engaging picky animals. What could be more simple than light-up balls for your cat to play with and chase around?

    From Catit Design, this package of two LED balls is motion activated. Whenever your cat even nudges them, they light up and engage your kitty’s hunting sense. Your cat can play with these apart from any other toy, or they can be included in some of the other Catit Design products. The balls are compatible with the Speed Circuit and the Play Circuit from the company.

    The outside of the balls is made with a smooth surface polyester. This means they easily move around rapidly, picking up speed and rolling to keep your cat moving to keep up. Since they light up, it is easier to find them when they inevitably roll underneath something.

    Pros
    • LED lights are motion-activated
    • Polyester exterior keeps the balls moving longer
    • Compatible with other toys from the company
    Cons
    • Separate play from another toy means they easily roll under furniture

    9.  Outward Hound Tail Teaser Pet Toy9Outward Hound Tail Teaser with Refill Dog & Cat Teaser Toy

    This toy from Outward Hound is extremely versatile because it can be used to entertain both cats and dogs. If you have a shared household, then this means playtime for everyone.

    The toy is simple, as it’s a long rod with a rope that dangles from the end. At the end of the rope, there are mouse-like toys. These can be caught, batted at, and held by a cat or bitten and tugged on by a dog.

    The nylon cord is durable to withstand tough tuggers. The mouse is made from faux fur, and it squeaks and rattles when it moves to keep them interested. There are two mouse toys included, and refills of the cord and mice are available for additional purchase.

    Pros
    • Replaceable parts are available for purchase
    • The toy can be used by both dogs and cats
    Cons
    • Not useful for self-play for animals
    • Basic design does not keep it interesting for that long with picky cats

    10. Hartz Just for Cats Peek & Play Pop-Up Tent Cat Toy10Hartz Just For Cats Peek & Play Pop-Up Tent Cat Toy

    Getting your cats a space that they identify as their personal home inside their home is a great way to keep them engaged. This pop-up tent from Hartz is rather small, though, making it a better toy for kittens than multiple full-grown cats.

    Inside of the pop-up tent is a couple of dangling balls that your cat can bat around while they are inside. There are also peek-a-boo holes that are covered with triangle cut-outs. Your cat can pop out of them to watch you or surprise their “prey.”

    The interior can have a detachable scratcher to keep your cats from scratching the furniture and help their nails grow healthy. The fabric inside has a crinkly texture, which is great fun for some cats but scares others.

    Pros
    • Multiple points of interest, including hanging balls and peek-a-boo holes
    • Detachable scratcher included
    • Quick assembly
    Cons
    • Crinkle fabric can scare some cats
    • Small interior

    Buyer’s Guide

    Buying toys for cats is often quite difficult. One of the best ways to engage them is via their instinctual prey drive and their desire to hunt. If they see a toy as a form of prey, they will be more interested in capturing it than if they think that it is just a fluffy toy.

    There are other ideas to consider when picking out the perfect toy as well. Think about your cat and their preferences while you look through these options.

    Variety

    Cats tend to be highly intelligent creatures. They are typically quite curious and will want to explore new things. They also have a short attention span and need plenty of variety to continue to be engaged.

    If a toy comes with options to add variety, it is preferable to use the same methods to keep a cat interested. Some toys have additional pieces that you can buy to mix it up when your cat’s interest begins to wane.

    Your Cat’s Favorites

    Consider your cat’s favorites. If they have never shown any interest in feathers, buying them a feathery toy might not be the way to go. Do they like to pounce and prowl? Give them something to hunt and chase around the house.

    It is also important to understand what your cat doesn’t like. Some kitties hate loud noises. They get scared quickly and easily and will feel put off from their new toy if it starts to scream at them. These toys will end up being a total waste of money because your cat will be too frightened to even go near it.

    Self-Play Option

    Entertaining your cat for hours on end might seem like your job to their royal highnesses, but it isn’t in reality. We often don’t have time to play with our cats long enough to mentally exhaust them and prevent them from being destructive.

    If this is the case for you, then consider toys that have self-play options. Instead of a feather wand, get them a toy that you can turn on and they can play with when no one is around.

    Interactive for Multiple Pets

    Although some households are full as a single pet home, this is not often the case. Getting one cat often leads to adopting more of these lovable, mischievous creatures.

    If you have more than one kitty or intend to adopt more, then invest in toys that multiple cats can use at once. Playing together also helps them stay engaged for longer periods.

    cat paw dividerConclusion

    Many choices have been developed, from balls to feathers and remotely operated toys using batteries, to keep your cat engaged and happy. Engage their senses, and keep them moving with the best overall product on this list, the Catit Design Senses Circuit Cat Toy.

    If you are not sure what kind of toy keeps your cat interested for long periods, then stay low-key and budget-friendly. Bergan Turbo Scratcher is the way to go if you want to test out a new toy that will distract them from the furniture.

    All cats have something that will make them feel like a kitten again, even if they seem incredibly picky. It might take experimentation, but with a sea of options, it isn’t impossible.


    Featured image credit: Chendongshan, Shutterstock