Halloween can be a really fun time of year for tons of people, but oftentimes we overlook our kitties. While cats may not understand the concept of a holiday, they can absolutely appreciate new toys. Halloween toys come in a fun variety of spooky shapes and unusual colors, which can make them fun for you and your cat.
To help you not end up with a bum cat toy that breaks easily or isn’t much fun, we’ve reviewed the top Halloween cat toys for you!
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites (2023 Update)
Image
Product
Details
Best Overall
Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys & Treats
Box full of items
Three full-sized treat bags and five plush toys
Halloween-themed tunnel toy with dangling bat-shaped toy included
The Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys & Treats box is our pick for the best overall Halloween cat toy. This box isn’t a toy in itself, although it could be if your cat loves boxes. This box is stuffed full of fun Halloween goodies, including multiple varieties of treats, a tunnel toy, and five catnip plush toys. There are three Halloween-themed donut-shaped plushes and two spiders. This box offers up 30% savings than if you purchased all of the items separately.
Because you get so many items in this box, it is one of the more expensive Halloween product picks for your cat.
Pros
Box full of items
Includes three full-sized treat bags and five plush toys
Halloween-themed tunnel toy with dangling bat-shaped toy included
Plush toys are Halloween-themed and packed with catnip
The best Halloween cat toy for the money is the Frisco Halloween Skull Laser, especially if your cat loves laser toys. This laser gets you and your cat into the Halloween spirit by projecting a skull-shaped laser image wherever you point it. Some people report their kitties finding this toy more interesting than normal lasers because the image is larger. This toy is great for encouraging your cat to participate in high-energy but short play sessions, which is preferred by many cats. It comes with batteries already in it, so this laser is ready to go right out of the package.
Laser toys can cause damage to both pets’ and peoples’ eyes, so make sure to never point this toy directly at anyone, including your cat.
Pros
Best value
Skull-shaped laser image
May be more interesting to your cat than a typical laser
The Frisco Halloween Mansion 2-Story Cat House is a great Halloween toy, but it does retail for a premium price. This cardboard house features an enclosed bottom space with a cardboard scratcher base, as well as a cardboard scratcher second level, so your cat can choose how concealed they want to be while they scratch. It’s made to look like a cute haunted mansion, complete with ghosts, bats, spiders, mummies, and Halloween colors. This scratcher house is easy to put together and very lightweight. Many cats will take to this house right away, but you can also sprinkle catnip on the corrugated cardboard for added interest because it will fall into the crevices of the cardboard.
Pros
Offers enclosed and open scratching spaces
Cute Halloween look
Easy to put together
Lightweight
Ideal for sprinkling with catnip
Cons
Premium price
4. Frisco Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy – Best for Kittens
For kittens celebrating their first Halloween, the Frisco Halloween Teaser Wand Cat Toy is the top pick. This teaser wand measures 18 inches in length, and it comes with an attached toy with two plushies on it. There are two refill toys as well, with one featuring a toy with two plushes and the other featuring a pumpkin plush with feathers. Since this toy has multiple refills, it will withstand your kitten’s roughhousing. Wand toys are a great option for kittens because they burn energy and stimulate your kitty’s natural hunting instincts.
Some users have reported the cords on the toys being easily chewed through, so it’s important to keep them out of the reach of your kitten when you aren’t playing with them.
Pros
Teaser wand is long enough to keep your hands safe
Three toys included
Ideal for withstanding your kitten’s roughhousing
Helps burn excess energy
Stimulates hunting instincts
Cons
Cords may be easily chewed through
5. Disney Halloween Mickey & Minnie Mouse Plush Toys
The Disney Halloween Mickey & Minnie Mouse Plush toys are a good deal because there are four plush toys included in the package. Each of these plushies is shaped like Minnie and Mickey Mouse, but they are designed with a variety of Halloween themes, including candy corn and a spider web. One toy even includes a Minnie Mouse bow! Each of these toys is made with soft plush on the outside, but the insides are stuffed with crinkle paper and catnip to provide an enriching play experience for your cat.
Although these toys are sturdy, the manufacturer does recommend supervising your cat when they play with them to ensure they don’t tear them open and consume parts of the toy.
Pros
Four toys to a pack
Different Halloween theme on each toy
Soft plush exteriors
Interiors are stuffed with catnip and crinkle paper
Cons
Recommended to allow supervised play only
6. Star Wars Halloween R2-D2 & C-3PO Trick or Treaters Plush Toys
If you’re a Star Wars fan, then you’ll love the Star Wars Halloween R2-D2 & C-3PO Trick or Treaters Plush toys. These toys feature the beloved Star Wars characters dressed up in their Halloween best, with C-3PO dressed as a mummy and R2-D2 impersonating a ghost. The R2-D2 toy is a normal-sized plush toy, while the C-3PO toy is sized to be a kicker toy. Each toy is stuffed with catnip to encourage your cat to play.
Some people have reported these toys being larger than expected, so they may be too big for small cats and kittens to carry around.
Pros
Star Wars and Halloween themed toys
Two toys per pack
Plush toy and kicker toy
Stuffed with catnip
Cons
May be too large for small cats and kittens to carry
7. Frisco Halloween A-Paw-Thecary & Chop House Cat House
The Frisco Halloween A-Paw-Thecary & Chop House Cat House is a single-story scratcher house that can double as a hiding place or bed for your kitty. Each end of the house features a different building, with one end being a Halloween apothecary and the other being a “chop house” barbershop. This large toy is open on both ends so your cat won’t feel too confined, and the base is made from corrugated cardboard so your kitty can enjoy scratching the day away. The corrugation makes this toy perfect for catnip.
This toy retails for a more premium price than most of the other Halloween toys we’ve reviewed.
The Kong Halloween Refillables Hedgehog Toy is a great option for a toy that will retain its catnip goodness for a long time. This Halloween hedgehog has a small compartment on the belly that can be opened and stuffed with catnip. A small container of catnip is included as well, so you’ll be stocked up on refill catnip for a while. This is a budget-friendly toy that is fun for cats of all sizes.
The pocket closure on this toy is Velcro, which can tear or catch other things over time, leaving it less able to close, so it’s important to keep the Velcro clean and free of debris.
Pros
Refillable compartment keeps catnip fresh
Catnip is included
Budget-friendly toy
Small enough for small cats and kittens to enjoy
Cons
Velcro closure may lose efficacy over time
9. Disney Halloween Mickey Mouse Ghost Plush Kicker
The Disney Halloween Mickey Mouse Ghost Plush Kicker toy is a fun Halloween toy for the Disney lover in your home. This plush kicker features a ghost version of Mickey, including fabric ears that are perfect for chewing on during kicking sessions. It’s stuffed with catnip and crinkle paper to keep your cat entertained. It’s designed with rough players in mind, so this toy should stand up to kitty roughhousing.
This toy is a kicker toy, so it may be too large for kittens and small cats to carry around. Also, the manufacturer of this toy recommends you only allow your cat to play with it when supervised.
Pros
Plush kicker design
Cute Halloween Mickey Mouse with floppy ears
Contains catnip and crinkle paper
Designed to withstand roughhousing
Cons
May be too large for small cats and kittens to carry
The Kong Halloween Puzzlements Hideaway Dog Toy is a fun toy option for cats that like a challenge with their toys. This plush toy features purple feathers on top, as well as two tethered plush toys that can be hidden inside the toy. The body of the toy features crinkle paper, and the tethered toys are stuffed with catnip, so each part of this toy can entertain your cat individually or as a whole. This is a budget-friendly toy that is suitable for cats of all sizes.
Due to the tethers attached to this toy, it’s not recommended to let your cat play with it unattended since these can become wrapped around your cat.
Plush toy is stuffed with crinkle paper and tethered toys contain catnip
Budget-friendly toy
Cons
Not recommended for unsupervised play
Tethers may become wrapped around parts of your cat
Buyer’s Guide
Choosing the Right Halloween Toy for Your Cat
Lucky for you, there are no right or wrong answers when it comes to choosing cat toys. Cats can benefit from a regular rotation of new toys to maintain their interest in their toys and provide them with an overall more enriched life.
That doesn’t mean your cat doesn’t have toy preferences, though! Start with toys you know your cat will like, then toss in one or two toys you’re unsure of. You can always try to encourage interest in new toys and types of play to keep your cat active and happy.
Our Favorite Catnip Toy:
Great cat toys are crucial to keeping your cat happy and healthy. We love Hepper’s Catnip Stick Toy because it’s handmade in the USA, available in a cool range of colors, and sturdy enough to withstand your cat’s sharp claws. Best of all, you won’t find any filler here – just 100% organic catnip!
At Excited Cats, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!
Conclusion
We’ve reviewed our favorite spooky season toys to help you find the cutest and best Halloween toys to entertain your cat. The best overall toy is the Goody Box Halloween Cat Toys & Treats box, which is stuffed full of treats and toys for your cat. A great budget-friendly pick is the Frisco Halloween Skull Laser, which will up your cat laser game and impress all of your cat’s friends. If you’ve got the budget for a pricier option, our pick is the Frisco Halloween Mansion 2-Story Cat House.
Brooke spent nine years as a veterinary assistant before becoming a human nurse in 2013. Brooke loves all animals and currently shares a home with three dogs, two cats, five fish, and two snails. She has a soft spot for special needs animals and has a three-legged senior dog and an internet-famous cat with acromegaly and cerebellar hypoplasia. Brooke stays active with yoga and obtained her 200-hour yoga teacher certification in 2020, she also loves spending her free time researching and writing.
