We’re all tired of dealing with messy litter box cleanups. But the last thing that we want is a litter box liner that keeps tearing or simply doesn’t get the job done. That’s why we tracked down and created reviews of 10 of the best litter box liners out there.
We also developed a buyer’s guide to help you pick out the right litter box liners the first time. So, if you’re shopping for litter box liners, you’ve come to the right place!
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
|Best Overall||Jonny Cat Jumbo Litter Box Liners||
|Best Value||Fresh Step Drawstring Litter Box Liner||
|Premium Choice||Frisco Cat Pan Liners||
|Best for Kittens||Pet-n-Pet Cat Litter Box Liners||
|Cat's Pride Jumbo Litter Box Liners||
The 10 Best Litter Box Liners — Reviews & Top Picks 2021
1. Jonny Cat Heavy Duty Jumbo Litter Box Liners — Best Overall
|Count:||5 or 10|
|Size:||36” x 18”|
When you’re looking for the best overall litter box liner, you want Johnny Cat’s Heavy Duty Jumbo Litter Box Liners. Not only do they have a super thick and durable design, but they’re also tear-resistant. They come in both scented and unscented options, and they’re an outstanding mix of price and performance.
These litter box liners are extremely easy to use and have a drawstring design that enables you to swap out bags quickly and effectively. However, we do wish that there was a bulk option when purchasing these bags. While they’re not expensive and it’s not a huge deal to order more than a few packs, the extra packaging is a bit wasteful.
Still, your cat won’t tear these liners to shreds, and they do everything that you could want from a litter box liner.
2. Fresh Step Drawstring Litter Box Liner — Best Value
|Size:||30” x 17” or 36” x 19”|
Just because you’re tired of dealing with constant litter changes doesn’t mean you want to spend a ton of money to fix the problem. That’s where Fresh Step’s Drawstring Litter Box Liner comes into play. There are both scented and unscented options, and they’re extremely easy to use.
There are two size options available and both are extremely affordable. With so much versatility and usability, it’s not hard to see why these are the best litter box liners for the money.
However, they are budget liners, so, they’re not super tear-resistant. Still, unless you have heavy diggers, there shouldn’t be a problem. There also aren’t any bulk size options, but the per bag price for the smaller boxes is still outstanding.
3. Frisco Cat Pan Liners — Premium Choice
|Count:||5, 10, 20, or 40|
|Size:||32” x 18”|
If you’re looking for the best litter box liners out there and don’t care about the price, the Frisco Cat Pan Liners are outstanding. They’re super durable liners that have a tear-resistant design, which helps with heavy diggers.
They also have a drawstring, which is a notable feature of all the top litter box liners. Another nice feature is that you can try out these liners by getting a smaller pack, and if you like what you get, you can purchase a bulk option next time.
We do wish that there was a scented option available, but it’s not a big deal. Just keep in mind that even when you are purchasing these bags in bulk, you’re spending more per bag than you would with many other brands. Still, they’re extremely durable and effective.
4. Pet-n-Pet Cat Litter Box Liners — Best for Kittens
|Count:||7 or 14|
|Size:||34” x 18”|
The Pet-n-Pet Cat Litter Box Liners are easy-to-use, drawstring-design-style litter box liners. They come with anti-microbial coating to help keep everything sanitary, and at 2.36 mm thick, they’re among the thickest litter box liners out there.
This makes them great for the ultra-sharp and often clumsy kitten claws. Even better for the environmentally conscious is the fact that Pet-n-Pet makes each of these bags from recycled materials. Not only are you making litter box cleanup easier for yourself, but you’re also using an environmentally savvy product!
This does drive up the cost per bag, but if you’re looking to do what’s right for the planet, it’s worth the extra cost. Also, while these liners come in two different count sizes, neither is a real bulk option. But since the packaging is also environmentally friendly, as long as you order them at the same time, it’s not a big deal!
5. Cat’s Pride Jumbo Litter Box Liners
|Count:||15 or 30|
|Size:||36” x 18”|
Not every litter box needs the thickest litter box liners out there. So, if you have a cat that doesn’t do much digging, Cat’s Pride Jumbo Litter Box Liners can be a great way for you to get the convenience of a liner while saving a few bucks.
These are about half as thick as most other litter box liners, but they are tear-resistant and have a more durable construction design. Heavy diggers can tear them apart, but for every other cat, they should be fine. They’re easy to use with their drawstring design, and they come in bulk options that help drive down the per bag price.
However, they don’t have any smaller count options, which means if they don’t work for you the first time, you’re stuck with quite a few bags that you don’t want.
6. Nature’s Miracle Odor Control Cat Litter Box Liners
|Size:||39” x 22”|
Nature’s Miracle Odor Control Cat Litter Box Liners is a mix between the thickest litter box liners available and those on the thinner side. So, while they might not be the most durable bags out there, they’re thick enough for the average cat.
They also come with odor control technology and anti-bacterial coating, which means you’re getting premium features. Considering that the bags are extremely affordable, you’re getting these outstanding features at a phenomenal price.
However, they only come in bulk sizes, which means if you find out that you have a heavy digger after the fact, you could be in trouble. Still, they’re easy to use and come in a larger size that fits more litter boxes. You could do far worse than this litter box liner.
7. Van Ness Drawstring Cat Pan Liners
|Count:||10, 15, or 20|
|Size:||16” x 12”, 19” x 15”, or 22” x 18”|
With three different size options, the Van Ness Drawstring Cat Pan Liner is sure to fit your litter box perfectly. Since each bag has a 2 mm thickness, the chances of your cat tearing through it are slim. This is especially true considering that each bag uses three-ply technology, making it even more durable.
It also has a drawstring design that is easy to use, and Van Ness makes the bags from 65% recycled plastic. Since each bag is also extremely affordable, these are great for both your bank account and the environment!
We do wish that there was a scented option to help with odors, but that’s not a huge deal for most cat owners. While these are thick bags with three-ply technology, there have been complaints about the bag’s overall durability. They hold up well, but they just don’t compare to the top choices.
8. Fresh Kitty Jumbo Litter Box Liners & Ties
|Size:||35” x 18”|
While the twist-tie design of these bags isn’t bad, it’s simply not as user-friendly as the drawstring option. However, by forgoing the drawstrings, the manufacturer was able to drop the price, which means you get bags with odor control technology without needing to spend any more money. They also come in a bulk pack, which helps drive down the price, and they have scratch guard technology.
However, these are not thick litter box liners, so if you have a heavy digger, steer clear. They also only come in a bulk pack. So, if you find out that you really want drawstrings or that the bag isn’t thick enough for your cats, you’re left with a bunch of liners that you don’t want to use.
9. Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan Liners
|Count:||10 or 20|
|Size:||22” x 18”|
While most cat owners don’t want to deal with a sifting litter box liner, if you’re among those looking to save as much litter as possible between each change, then this type of box liner can help get the job done.
However, there are clear drawbacks to the sifting litter box design. First, it’s more apt to tear, given that the bags already have small holes throughout. If your cat gets a claw in one of these holes, they’ll stretch it out.
Second, these liners make more of a mess than any other litter box liner. There’s no way to avoid this, and it defeats the purpose of a litter box liner for many cat owners.
Still, these do help save litter, Van Ness uses a three-ply technology with these bags, and it made them from 100% recycled plastic. When you consider how affordable these are per bag, they’re not a bad deal.
10. Petmate Litter Pan Boxed Liners
|Count:||8 or 12|
|Size:||31.75” x 17.5” or 36.75” x 19”|
The Petmate Litter Pan Boxed Liners are among the thinnest litter box liners out there. That means they’re more prone to tearing, and that’s the last thing that you want with a litter box liner. They also don’t come with a drawstring design. This makes them a little more challenging to use. Finally, they don’t have any odor control technology. They’re not doing anything special and that’s a shame.
However, they are extremely affordable and come in two different size options. If your cats don’t dig, then these litter box liners can get the job done at a fraction of the cost.
If you still have a few questions about what litter box liner is right for you, then you’ve come to the right place. We created a guide to walk you through the most important decisions that you need to make before selecting a litter box liner.
Verifying the Fit
It doesn’t matter what features a litter box liner has if it doesn’t fit your litter box. The easiest way to determine if the liner will fit your litter box is to get the dimensions of your litter box and compare them to those of the liner.
Each liner on our list highlights which size boxes it will fit, so once you have your litter box dimensions, you should be good to go! But always double-check because the last thing that you want is to get a bunch of litter box liners in the mail that won’t fit!
Litter Box Liner Styles
After verifying that your litter box liner fits your litter box, you need to pick a liner style. There are three main styles to choose from, and we broke down the differences between each one here.
It’s one of the top choices for litter box liners, and it’s not even close. Drawstring liners easily attach to the top of litter boxes, and they make it very easy to change the liner.
When you’re ready to change the liner, you simply take it off, pull the drawstrings, tie it, and throw it away! If you need a tighter cinch around the top of the litter box, you can pull the drawstrings to get it there.
Drawstring liners are among the most popular types of litter box liners out there, but they are a little more expensive than the twist-tie options.
Before drawstring litter box liners existed, it was all about the twist ties. These litter box liners don’t have the drawstring design, but in every other way, they’re identical.
They’ll often come with rubber bands to help you attach them to the top of the litter box, and you’ll need to use twist ties to tie them off when you’re changing them. They’re not overly complicated to use, but they’re not as convenient as the drawstring options.
Tons of people have ordered a sifting litter box liner without realizing what they’re getting — don’t be one of those people. Sifting litter box liners have holes all along the bottom of the liner. This enables the unused litter to sift through back into the litter box.
While this helps you save litter, it also is far messier. In many ways, it defeats the purpose of a liner in the first place. However, it can make cleanup a little easier, and it does enable you to save and reuse as much clean litter as possible.
The last thing that you want with a litter box liner is to have the bag tear on you when you’re using it. That’s where bag thickness comes into play. The thicker the bag, the more it can handle.
Moreover, since many cats like to dig in their litter box, a thicker bag reduces the chances that they’ll tear through it. When you’re looking at the overall durability of a litter box liner, bag thickness is the most important factor to consider.
Scented vs. Unscented
Some people love litter box liners because a scented one can help control the odor. Others are allergic to the scents, which leaves them with fewer options.
In the end, there’s no right or wrong choice of scented or unscented litter box liners; it all comes down to personal (and your cat’s) preference. But keep in mind that scented litter box liners are typically a little more expensive than their unscented counterparts.
You can also use granules or other odor-controlling mechanisms if you’re not interested in a scented litter box liner.
If you’re still confused about which litter box liner to purchase after reading through these reviews, don’t overthink it. There’s a reason that the Johnny Cat Heavy Duty Jumbo Litter Box Liners is the top choice. It’s extremely durable and effective, and that’s all you want in a litter box liner.
Of course, if you’re looking to save a few bucks, then the Fresh Step Drawstring Litter Box Liner is an outstanding choice too. So, what are you waiting for? Order a litter box liner and simplify your litter box cleanup!
Featured Image Credit: Freepik
- A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites
- The 10 Best Litter Box Liners — Reviews & Top Picks 2021
- 1. Jonny Cat Heavy Duty Jumbo Litter Box Liners — Best Overall
- 2. Fresh Step Drawstring Litter Box Liner — Best Value
- 3. Frisco Cat Pan Liners — Premium Choice
- 4. Pet-n-Pet Cat Litter Box Liners — Best for Kittens
- 5. Cat’s Pride Jumbo Litter Box Liners
- 6. Nature’s Miracle Odor Control Cat Litter Box Liners
- 7. Van Ness Drawstring Cat Pan Liners
- 8. Fresh Kitty Jumbo Litter Box Liners & Ties
- 9. Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan Liners
- 10. Petmate Litter Pan Boxed Liners
- Buyer’s Guide