ExcitedCats is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Soulistic Cat Food Review 2021: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary

Our Final Verdict

We give Soulistic Cat Food a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars.

Introduction

Soulistic Cat Food often receives high praise and top-quality rankings with its simple formulas marketed to not only feed your cat’s body but also to “feed your cat’s soul.” In this review, we deep-dive into the brand to determine if it is healthy, breed-specific, and an overall safe choice for your cat.

We believe that the brand is species-appropriate, and the quality of its ingredients and recipes are top-notch. Although the price can make it difficult for budget buyers to afford, overall, many cat owners say that it is worth it.

At a Glance: The Best Soulistic Cat Food Recipes

Image Product Details
Our Favorite
Winner
Soulistic Luna Tuna Dinner in Pumpkin Soup Cat Food Pouches Soulistic Luna Tuna Dinner in Pumpkin Soup Cat Food Pouches
  • Feature iconExcellent for weight management
  • Feature iconResponsibly sourced ingredients
  • Feature iconHealthy amount of protein and taurine
  • Best Gelee Recipe
    Second place
    Soulistic Polynesian Picnic Chicken & Tilapia Dinner in Gelee Wet Soulistic Polynesian Picnic Chicken & Tilapia Dinner in Gelee Wet
  • Feature iconResponsibly-sourced seafood
  • Feature iconFirst ingredients are meat-based proteins
  • Feature iconGluten-free
  • Best Chicken Recipe
    Third place
    Soulistic Aromatic Chicken Chicken Dinner in Gelee Wet Cat Food Soulistic Aromatic Chicken Chicken Dinner in Gelee Wet Cat Food
  • Feature iconChicken is a primary ingredient
  • Feature iconLimited-ingredient recipe
  • Feature iconLimits non-species-appropriate foods
  • Best Seafood Recipe
    Soulistic Midnight Delight Mackerel & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Adult Soulistic Midnight Delight Mackerel & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Adult
  • Feature iconMackerel & Tuna ingredients
  • Feature iconProvides vitamins and minerals
  • Best for Breed
    Soulistic Moist & Tender Tuna & Salmon Dinner in Gravy Wet Cat Food Soulistic Moist & Tender Tuna & Salmon Dinner in Gravy Wet Cat Food
  • Feature iconMade with Red Meat Tuna and wild caught Salmon
  • Feature iconGrain, gluten, carrageenan, MSG, BPA and GMO free
  • Feature iconProvides high moisture
  • Cat ball divider 1

    Soulistic Cat Food Reviewed

    Soulistic Cat Food is not a common cat food brand and is somewhat tricky to track down unless you have a provider in your region. However, the brand is growing in popularity because it uses recipes that tend to be highly breed-aware.

    Who Makes Soulistic Cat Food and Where Is It Produced?

    Weruva produces Soulistic Cat Food. Weruva is a family-owned pet food manufacturer based in the U.S. It produces Soulistic as a Petco-exclusive food brand.

    David and Stacie Forman founded Weruva in 2006. The brand came to be known for its high-moisture food high in protein and meat-based and its formulas that have simple recipes with few ingredients.

    Unfortunately, even though Weruva is based in the U.S., Soulistic formulas are produced in a facility in Thailand. The facility does maintain the highest level certifications put out by the British Retail Consortium even though the food-grade quality standards in Thailand are much lower.

    Which Types of Cats Is Soulistic Best Suited For?

    Soulistic Cat Food is best for cats that prefer wet food. All of Soulistic’s current cat food recipes are wet, canned, or bagged foods. If your cat prefers a wet food texture, they will likely love this food.

    The Soulistic wet foods are also best for cats with food allergies to the preservatives and additives commonly found in other cat foods. Soulistic makes a point of keeping its formulas simple, filling them with limited ingredients. It also keeps the quality of these ingredients at the forefront of its formula policies.

    Which Types of Cats Might Do Better With a Different Brand?

    Some cats do not enjoy the texture of wet food as much as eating dry kibble. If your cat needs a limited-ingredient cat food but prefers dry food, you can try Natural Balance’s L.I.D. Dry Cat Food.

    Soulistic Midnight Delight Mackerel & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Adult Cat Food Pouches

    Discussion of the Primary Ingredients (Good and Bad)

    When you look for food for your pet, you should always consider their diet in the wild. Try to find food whose ingredient analysis breaks down in a similar way to their natural diet. This focus for a brand or buyer is called “species-appropriateness.” It means that your cat is getting everything that they need without getting things they don’t. Soulistic does a decent job of balancing this in their wet food.

    Moisture Content

    When it comes to wet food, you will have high moisture levels. These are essential for preserving the food inside. As long as you don’t see water as one of the first ingredients, you should be fine.

    Water actually isn’t the best way that companies can get to their desired moisture levels. For example, in some of Soulistic’s recipes, fish or chicken broth make up the moisture levels. This means the liquid in the food also contributes to the recipe’s nutritional value. Most of Soulistic’s foods have a maximum moisture level of 85%.

    First Ingredients

    When looking into a new recipe for your cat, it is always best to examine the ingredient list thoroughly. The first ingredients are always those that are in the highest quantity in the recipe. In food for a carnivore, this should be the meat that it claims to have.

    The first ingredients should not include fillers, like brewer’s yeast, grains, or rice. None of these contain much nutritional value. Instead, they make your cat feel full quickly. They eat less, and what they do eat does not have as much nutrition as it should.

    Look for the top ingredients to be meat or some kind of vegetable that provides protein in the food. High enough protein levels are the most crucial factors in a cat’s diet.

    grey cat eating meat
    Image Credit: Chendongshan, Shutterstock

    Taurine Levels

    Taurine is an essential amino acid. It only occurs naturally in animal-based proteins. That is why it is essential for cats to not get their food only from vegetables, even legumes that contain protein. The amino acids are not the same and will not provide them with the diet that they need.

    In a cat, taurine is essential for them to form and maintain their digestive functions, normal vision, and the function of their heart and other organs. It is needed in even more significant amounts for pregnant cats if you want the fetuses to develop as they should. It also boosts your cat’s immune system.

    Although you can find taurine in the breakdown of animal meats included in the recipe, it is a good indicator if it is a separate ingredient. Soulistic Cat Foods include it as such, meaning your cat will get plenty of this essential amino acid in each bite.

    Unnecessary Extras

    There are many foods sold for dogs and cats that contain unhealthy fillers. Keep an eye out for them in any recipe that you buy for your cat. Each bite that contains fillers deprives your pet of the nutrition that should be in that bite. Try to avoid foods with unnecessary extras.

    Soulistic Cat Food does not contain any fillers. It provides cat owners with a gluten-free diet. One controversial ingredient that it does contain is tapioca starch, which is unnecessary for anything except to thicken the consistency of the food. It increases the level of carbohydrates in the food as well. That is not a good thing for felines.

    divider-catclaw1

    A Quick Look at Soulistic Cat Food

    Soulistic Moist & Tender Tuna & Salmon Dinner in Gravy Wet Cat Food

    Pros
    • Healthy first ingredients
    • Relatively species-appropriate
    • Rich in taurine
    • Gluten-free
    Cons
    • Not produced in the U.S.A.
    • Higher levels of carbohydrates than necessary

    Recall History

    Soulistic Cat Food has never been recalled. The closest recall related to this food brand is that of B.F.F., or Best Feline Friend, produced by Weruva. B.F.F. had a recall in 2017 when the canned products sold in Australia didn’t contain sufficient thiamine levels to maintain a cat’s health. These products had been isolated and produced for the Australian market and were only recalled in Australia.

    cat + line divider

    Reviews of the 3 Best Soulistic Cat Food Recipes

    Soulistic Cat Food has a small number of options for a variety of recipes and formulas. However, of those options, it tries to keep as species-appropriate and straightforward as possible. Although these come with heftier price tags, you may well decide that they are worth it.

    1. Soulistic Luna Tuna Dinner in Pumpkin Soup Cat Food Pouches

    Soulistic Luna Tuna Dinner in Pumpkin Soup Cat Food Pouches

    Soulistic’s Luna Tuna dinner is our number-one choice for the best of its cat food recipes. The company works hard to source all of its ingredients from high-quality and environmentally-friendly industries. It ensures that all the tuna for this recipe is responsibly sourced, ensuring that it did not harm dolphins or sea turtles.

    This recipe is not only good for the environment, but it is also quite good for your cat’s weight health. Many house cats battle with maintaining a healthy weight. Thus, this meal is made with the intent to curb weight gain.

    The only downside that we can see to this recipe is the inclusion of a thickening agent, tapioca starch. The ingredient increases the number of carbohydrates in the food. Otherwise, it contains plenty of protein and taurine in easily digestible forms for your furry friend.

    Calorie Breakdown:

    Soulistic Luna Tuna Pouch Review

    Pros
    • Excellent for weight management
    • Responsibly sourced ingredients
    • Healthy amount of protein and taurine
    Cons
    • Contains tapioca starch
    thematic break

    2. Soulistic Polynesian Picnic Chicken & Tilapia Dinner in Gelee Wet Cat Food

    Soulistic Polynesian Picnic Chicken & Tilapia Dinner in Gelee Wet Cat Food

    Soulistic’s Polynesian Picnic is a delectable recipe that includes chicken and tilapia in a gelée texture that cats love. It is another excellent example of environmentally-friendly sourcing. The companies that provide Soulistic with tuna and tilapia use lines instead of nets because nets are dangerous to many other kinds of sea creatures.

    Like all of Soulistic’s other formulas, this food doesn’t contain any grains. It is entirely gluten-free. It also doesn’t contain fruits and vegetables, which are unnecessary for a cat’s diet. However, the food does contain tapioca starch, which takes its carbohydrate level to an unhealthy amount.

    This food could be slightly more species-appropriate if the company used animal-sourced fat as its primary fat source. Instead, the recipe includes sunflower seed oil, which isn’t as digestible for most cats. It also uses xanthan gum as the binding agent. Although xanthan gum is one of the better binding agents in cat food, it might still trigger allergic reactions. It is neither species-appropriate nor nutritious.

    Calorie Breakdown:

    Soulistic Polynesian Picnic Chicken & Tilapia Dinner - In Gelée Review

    Pros
    • Responsibly-sourced seafood
    • First ingredients are meat-based proteins
    • Gluten-free
    Cons
    • Contains controversial ingredients
    thematic break

    3. Soulistic Aromatic Chicken Chicken Dinner in Gelée Wet Cat Food

     

    Soulistic Aromatic Chicken Chicken Dinner in Gelee Wet Cat Food

    Soulistic commonly uses fish in their wet cat food meals. Chicken is the main ingredient after sufficient water for processing. This formula uses minimal ingredients to minimize the chances of your cat suffering from an allergic reaction to non-species-appropriate foods.

    Although chicken is the number-two ingredient in this Soulistic recipe, those that follow are not the best. The company could use animal fat instead of sunflower seed oil to make the fats more usable for cats. It is also best if cat foods do not contain ingredients like guar and locust bean gum, since these increase the amount of carbohydrates in the food.

    The food does provide cats with plenty of digestible protein and taurine, along with all the other vitamin supplements that cats need to maintain healthy immune and digestive systems.

    Calorie Breakdown:

    Soulistic Chicken Dinner In Gelée Review

    Pros
    • Chicken is a primary ingredient
    • Limited-ingredient recipe
    • Limits non-species-appropriate foods
    Cons
    • Includes controversial ingredients
    • Higher in carbs

    cat face divider 2

    What Other Users Are Saying

    It is always helpful to get feedback from other users and evaluators of a brand. Check out what other people have said about Soulistic Cat Food and its effect on the health of cats.

    • AllAboutCats: “Customers appreciate the value of Soulistic Cat Food as a relatively low-cost alternative to Weruva. Most say their cats enjoy the food.”
    • My Pet Needs That: “All ingredients used for the Soulistic Cat Food recipes were sourced from incredibly credible backgrounds.”
    • Amazon: As pet owners, we always double-check with Amazon reviews from buyers before we buy something. You can read these by clicking here.

    cat paw divider

    Conclusion

    Soulistic Cat Food is, overall, a good cat food that remains average to good in many categories, including quality of ingredients, species-appropriateness, and quality of production. The company works hard to ensure that the food is high-grade even though it is not produced in America. If you need a wet cat food that is gluten-free and minimizes the number of ingredients involved, you can give Soulistic a try, knowing that it is likely to be food that your cat will enjoy.