ExcitedCats is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Top 10 Cat Foods That Have Never Been Recalled 2021 – Reviews & Top Picks

Budget Cat Foods

Cats are fussy creatures, and sometimes selecting their food can be more stressful than choosing what to eat ourselves! Usually, once you and your cat know and like a brand, it makes sense to stick with it for the duration.

There can be times, however, that it makes sense to switch to a new brand. One of those times is a product recall. Cat food gets recalled by either the manufacturer or the FDA, and it can be a scary moment to realize that you’ve been feeding your cat something that could be making them ill.

At this point, it makes perfect sense to switch brands, but the sheer number of choices can be overwhelming. Luckily, our reviews are here to help. We’ve rounded up 10 of the best cat foods that have never been recalled. Take a look to find one that will suit your cat.

A Quick Overview (updated in 2021)

Image Product Details
Best Overall
Winner
Ziwi Peak Canned Ziwi Peak Canned
  • 10% protein & 4% fat
  • Also available in other flavors
  • Mackerel as the first ingredient
  • Best Value
    Second place
    Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack
  • 9-11% protein depending on the flavor
  • Case of 24 cans
  • Contains meat or fish as the first ingredient
  • Premium Choice
    Third place
    Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Canned Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Canned
  • Grain-free
  • Suitable for all life stages
  • Includes fish as the first ingredient
  • Meow Mix Tender Favorites Food Trays Meow Mix Tender Favorites Food Trays
  • Contains 10-11% protein
  • Great value for money
  • Two case sizes available
  • Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry
  • Contains 40% protein
  • Uses premium ingredients
  • Available in two bag sizes
  • The Top 10 Cat Foods That Have Never Been Recalled

    1. Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe Canned Cat Food — Best Overall

    Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe Canned Cat Food

    Taking the top spot as the best overall cat food that has never been recalled, we have the Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe Canned Cat Food. This cat food is specifically designed to emulate a whole-prey style diet, so this wet food contains bones and organs, as well as meat. About 92% of each can is made up of meat, New Zealand green mussels, and organs, so you know this is brimming with natural goodness for your cat.

    Ziwi Peak canned cat food is formulated to meet the nutritional requirements of all cat breeds and life stages, so if you have a multi-cat household, this is an excellent choice to keep them all in the best of health.

    Pros
    • Available in two case sizes
    • Mackerel as the first ingredient
    • Contains 10% protein and 4% fat
    • Also available in other flavors
    Cons
    • None that we can see

    2. Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Canned Cat Food — Best Value

    Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Canned Cat Food

    Taking the spot for the best cat food that has never been recalled for the money, we have the Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Canned Cat Food. This variety pack contains four different mouthwatering flavors to keep your cat happy and healthy on a budget. Each can includes a touch of milk, to make the Fancy Feast palatable for even fussy eaters.

    Of course, this recipe includes all the essential nutrients, minerals, and vitamins to keep your cat looking their best. This is a great choice if your cat loves a variety of flavors and textures, as this pack includes chunks of meat in gravy and pâté.

    Pros
    • Case of 24 cans
    • Contains meat or fish as the first ingredient
    • 9-11% protein depending on the flavor
    • Many flavors to choose from
    Cons
    • Milk may upset some cat’s tummies

    3. Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Canned Cat Food — Premium Choice

    Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Canned Cat Food

    As our choice of a premium cat food that has never been recalled, we recommend the Earthborn Holistic Monterey Medley Canned Cat Food. This blend is designed to satisfy your cat’s craving for meat. This blend uses skipjack and tuna as the first two ingredients, but there are many other flavors available if your cat prefers!

    Earthborn Holistic uses only premium ingredients selected specifically for its nutritional benefits. Founded in 1926, the company has four-generations’ worth of knowledge, which is all put towards formulating the best food for your cat, using only the finest ingredients.

    Pros
    • Other flavors available
    • Grain-free
    • Includes fish as the first ingredient
    • Suitable for all life stages
    Cons
    • Expensive

    4. Meow Mix Tender Favorites Poultry & Beef Cat Food Trays

    Meow Mix Tender Favorites Poultry & Beef Cat Food Trays

    If your cat loves the variety of different wet foods, then this multi-pack of Meow Mix Tender Favorites Poultry & Beef Cat Food Trays will keep them happy with three different flavors, all of which contain plenty of real meat.

    Formulated for cats of all life stages, the Meow Mix Tender Favorites is a great choice if you have a multi-cat household and are looking for wet food that can be fed to all ages. The easy-open cups contain individual portions, and it’s easy to simply pour the food into your cat’s bowl, with no worries about scraping the last bit out!

    Pros
    • Two case sizes available
    • Great value for money
    • Contains 10-11% protein
    Cons
    • Some flavors contain meat by-products
    • Contains grains

    5. Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

    Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

    The Earthborn Holistic Primitive Feline Grain-Free Dry Cat Food is a high-protein food designed to fuel your cat’s growth spurts and active lifestyle. Having turkey and chicken meal as the first ingredients means this is packed full of meat protein, which is complemented by a range of nutritious vegetables and fruits.

    Containing no grain or gluten, it’s a great choice for cats with sensitive digestive systems. But do be aware that it does contain egg, which some cats can react to. The premium ingredients used in Earthborn Holistic recipes are rigorously tested before use, so you can be confident in their safety and nutritional quality. Also, this brand has never had a recall!

    Pros
    • Contains 40% protein
    • Available in two bag sizes
    • Uses premium ingredients
    Cons
    • Expensive
    • Contains egg and peas

    6. Annamaet Grain-Free Chicken & Fish Dry Cat Food

    Annamaet Grain-Free Chicken & Fish Dry Cat Food

    Annamaet foods have been in production since 1986, and the company has never had a recall. Annamaet Grain-Free Chicken & Fish Dry Cat Food uses chicken and herring meal as the main source of protein, which sits at an impressive 44%.

    Algae is added as a source of omega-3 fatty acids, as well as chelated minerals to help your cat’s immune system function at its best. This is a great blend, but we wouldn’t recommend feeding it to an overweight cat due to its high-fat content. If your cat is underweight, though, it’s a good choice!

    Pros
    • Two bag sizes available
    • Suitable for all life stages
    Cons
    • Expensive
    • Contains egg
    • Not suitable for overweight cats

    7. Holistic Select Indoor Health Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

    Holistic Select Indoor Health Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

    If you’re looking for dry cat food that’s specifically formulated to support the health of your indoor cat, this is Holistic Select Indoor Heath Grain-Free Dry Cat Food for you. It’s created with 30% less fat than the standard Holistic Health recipes, meaning it’s well suited for indoor cats who can be prone to getting overweight.

    While it might contain less fat, it still contains plenty of quality ingredients, including turkey, chicken, and a blend of fruits, vegetables, vitamins, and minerals, all designed to help your indoor cat be their best from the inside out.

    Pros
    • Available in three bag sizes
    • Contains no by-products
    • Grain-free
    Cons
    • Best suited for indoor cats only
    • May not have enough calories for active cats
    • Expensive

    8. Nature’s Logic Feline Chicken Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

    Nature’s Logic Feline Chicken Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

    Nature’s Logic Feline Chicken Feast Grain-Free Canned Cat Food is the perfect complement to the Nature’s Logic kibble that we featured as our best overall choice, although of course, these cans contain 100% balanced nutrition on their own.

    If your cat has allergies or sensitivities, this is a good option because it’s free from any lentils, wheat, corn, soy, potato, peas, or rice. Using real chicken products as the first four ingredients is a good indication that this wet food is formulated with the needs of your cat as an obligate carnivore.

    Pros
    • 100% natural ingredients
    • Chicken as the first ingredient
    Cons
    • Expensive
    • Small can size
    • Does contain egg

    9. Now Fresh Grain-Free Adult Recipe Dry Cat Food

    Now Fresh Grain-Free Adult Recipe Dry Cat Food

    The Now Fresh Grain-Free Adult Recipe Dry Cat Food contains 31% protein, thanks to the high content of turkey, salmon, and duck. Your cat will get plenty of omega-3 and -6 from the inclusion of canola and coconut oils.

    The gluten- and the grain-free formula doesn’t contain any soy, wheat, gluten or fillers. It also doesn’t have any meat by-products or rendered meat, so you can be sure you’re giving your cat the best nutrition. What it does contain are pre- and probiotics to help digestive health, as well as plenty of healthy fruits and vegetables.

    Pros
    • Available in three bag sizes
    Cons
    • Not suitable for kittens
    • Expensive
    • Contains egg

    10. Meow Mix Tender Centers Salmon & White Meat Dry Cat Food

    Meow Mix Tender Centers Salmon & White Meat Dry Cat Food

    The Meow Mix Tender Centers Salmon & White Meat Dry Cat Food is available in two bag sizes and offers great value for money from a well-trusted brand that has never had a recall. With 31% protein, this kibble is designed to tempt your fussy cat to eat, thanks to the irresistible flavor. Each piece of kibble is crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, a combination your cat should enjoy.

    While this is a great budget option, it does contain a few ingredients that you won’t see in some of the brands higher up our list. These include corn and meat by-products, as well as artificial colorings and flavorings.

    Pros
    • Made in the U.S.A.
    Cons
    • Corn as the first ingredient
    • Contains meat by-products
    • Contains colorings
    • Contains flavorings

    Buyer’s Guide

    If your cat’s normal food is subject to a recall, it can be a scary experience. If that’s happened to you, it’s understandable that you might want to switch to a different brand of cat food that has never been recalled.

    In this guide, we’re going to provide more information about exactly what a pet food recall entails and why it matters.

    Why would a cat food be recalled?

    If customers complain to the FDA that cat food has made their pet sick, smells rancid, or is otherwise faulty in some way, then the FDA will investigate and test this product. They may find dangerous levels of certain ingredients or the presence of bacteria that has the potential to make your cat sick.

    At this point, the FDA will issue a recall. These can either be a requested recall, or a statutory recall. Manufacturers are then obliged to request that customers return any product to them or their stockers and to issue a full refund.

    Cat foods can also be recalled by the manufacturer if they suspect something is wrong. Sometimes, this can indicate a less serious issue, such as incorrect labeling on the packaging. Other times, manufacturers will recall a cat food themselves in advance of an FDA recall being issued, to try and minimize the damage to their brand.

    Either way, having a cat food recalled is not something that any brand would want. It can damage their reputation with customers and of course, have serious implications for whether their brand will continue to be purchased.

    How do I know if my cat food brand has ever had a recall?

    There are a couple of ways to go about this. Of course, by choosing one of the brands in this review, you can be confident that they’ve never had a recall!

    You can also go onto the FDA website and browse through their list of recalled pet foods. Each recall will be listed with information on the date, brand name, product description, the reason for the recall, and the name of the company.


    cat paw divider

    Conclusion

    Now you know a little bit more about how and why cat foods can be recalled, you’ve probably realized how important it is to choose a trustworthy brand of cat food that’s never had a recall.

    As a reminder, as the best overall cat food that has never had a recall, we selected the Ziwi Peak Mackerel & Lamb Recipe Canned Cat Food. Ziwi Peak uses only the finest ingredients, including real meat, bones, and organs designed to help your obligate carnivore cat feel and look their best.

    As the best value choice, we recommend the Fancy Feast Creamy Delights Variety Pack Canned Cat Food. This cat food contains all the vitamins, minerals, and nutrients that your cat needs to stay healthy, but is also friendly on your wallet!

    We hope that our reviews have helped you to decide which brand of cat food will be the perfect choice for your precious cat. After all, they have to trust us to choose the best type of food for their needs, and selecting one from a list of brands that have never suffered a recall is a great place to start!


    Featured Image: Pexels